All Makeup Skin Hair Nails How-To Beauty Amplified Spoilers IPSY 101 Wellness Ingredient Index

Is the New BADgal Bounce Benefit's Best Mascara Yet? Let’s Find Out

Maddie Aberman DefaultMaddie Aberman Default
By
Published on Jan 27, 2025 • 4 min read
benefit-bad-gal-bounce-mascara-review mobilebenefit-bad-gal-bounce-mascara-review desktop

I’ll be honest: In my 11+ years as a beauty editor, I’ve tried a lot of mascaras. From drugstore finds to luxury splurges, I’ve tested formulas promising everything from doll-like lashes to gravity-defying lift. But as someone with lashes that are naturally long yet straight, light, and prone to clumping, I’m pretty picky. Like, “hold-it-under-a-magnifying-glass-to-check-for-clumps” picky. My current tried-and-true heroes include E.L.F. COSMETICS Lash It Loud Mascara in Deep Brown (if you haven’t tried brown mascara, what are you doing?!), MAYBELLINE NEW YORK Great Lash Big® Washable Mascara, and my all-time favorite BENEFIT COSMETICS Roller Lash Mascara—I’ve probably gone through 15 tubes of the stuff. 

So when I heard the makers of my Holy Grail mascara were back at it with a brand-new launch, the BADgal Bounce Volumizing Mascara, I was skeptical if it could live up to my Roller Lash standards. Spoiler alert: This mascara delivers in ways me and my lashes weren’t even ready for.

benefit-bad-gal-bounce-mascara-review 01

It's about glam time you treated yourself.

Join IPSY
Default Middle Subscribe Module Image - MobileDefault Middle Subscribe Module Image - Desktop

What You Need to Know About BENEFIT BADgal Bounce Volumizing Mascara

BADgal Bounce is all about lashes that are bouncy, fluffy, and volumized—minus the drama of clumps or flakes. The brand’s custom-engineered dual-sided brush combines two textures: a fluffy, curved side for coating and volumizing lashes and a firm, fine-tooth comb side for defining and separating them. The formula is also packed with good-for-lash ingredients, like linden bud extract to help boost fullness, rice wax to keep that lift locked in, and castor seed oil to nourish. Oh, and did I mention it’s smudge-proof, transfer-proof, and flake-proof?

benefit-bad-gal-bounce-mascara-review 02

My First Impressions

On my first try, I started with one coat using the fluffier side of the brush. My lashes immediately looked longer and fuller, with a natural-looking false-lash effect—like those DIY lash extensions that blend seamlessly into your natural lash line. No clumps, no fuss, just soft, fanned-out volume.

The fine-tooth comb side became my secret weapon for lower lashes. I’m back on a lower-lash mascara kick lately, and this side of the wand coated my lower lashes with just the right amount of pigment without veering into clumpy territory.

Even after tapping the wand against my lashes for a solid 20 minutes trying to secure the perfect selfies for this review (don’t judge!), the clumpage was minimal. If that’s not impressive, I honestly don’t know what is.

benefit-bad-gal-bounce-mascara-review 03

The BENEFIT BADgal Bounce Masara Wear Test

It is no exaggeration to say that this stuff stayed put through my whole entire day—no flakes, no smudges, not a raccoon eye in sight—even with my deep-set eyes that tend to fall victim to all of the above. From my morning company all-hands meeting to my nighttime catch-up of The Traitors season three, my lashes looked as flawless at 8 p.m. as they did at 8 a.m.

Honorable mention for how easy to end-of-day removal was, too. I double cleanse every night (cleansing balm first, then a gentle foaming cleanser), and the mascara came off easily after step one without tugging or residue left behind.

Final Thoughts

BADgal Bounce is officially a new staple in my makeup collection. It gives you natural, fluffy volume with zero hassle, and the dual-sided brush makes application customizable for your lash goals. Whether you’re going for barely-there daytime lashes or full-blown drama, this mascara has your back, well.. lashes.

Liked this post? Share!

UP NEXT: I Tried the KULFI BEAUTY Main Match Concealer—Hello, Glow!

Related Stories

Selena Gomez attends the 83rd Annual Golden Globe Awards at The Beverly Hilton on January 11, 2026 in Beverly Hills, California.Selena Gomez attends the 83rd Annual Golden Globe Awards at The Beverly Hilton on January 11, 2026 in Beverly Hills, California.

Makeup

Pass the Glam! 8 Thanksgiving Makeup Looks Inspired by Your Favorite Celebs

4 min read

Cheerful friends doing make-up while enjoying in party at homeCheerful friends doing make-up while enjoying in party at home

Makeup

The Beauty Products Every Host Should Keep in the Bathroom

6 min read

Foundation cushion with sponge and puff on white backgroundFoundation cushion with sponge and puff on white background

Makeup

Wait, Are We All Using Cushion Foundation Now?

3 min read

Portrait of a beautiful woman with natural make-upPortrait of a beautiful woman with natural make-up

Makeup

How to Fake 8 Hours of Sleep With Makeup

5 min read

Gabrielle Union attends the Schiaparelli Haute Couture Spring-Summer 2025 show as part of Paris Fashion Week on January 27, 2025 in Paris, France.Gabrielle Union attends the Schiaparelli Haute Couture Spring-Summer 2025 show as part of Paris Fashion Week on January 27, 2025 in Paris, France.

Makeup

These Makeup Looks Are So Scorpio-Coded

3 min read

Three shades of BENEFIT COSMETICS The POREfessional Concealer in clear tubes with white caps, displayed on a white pedestal against a bright pink background.Three shades of BENEFIT COSMETICS The POREfessional Concealer in clear tubes with white caps, displayed on a white pedestal against a bright pink background.

Makeup

I Put BENEFIT's New POREfessional Concealer to the Test—Here's My Verdict

5 min read

four perfume bottles on white background, seen in a sunlight and shadowsfour perfume bottles on white background, seen in a sunlight and shadows

Makeup

Why Everyone’s Scent Stacking Right Now

4 min read

An image of the three classic perfumes against a rainbow backgroundAn image of the three classic perfumes against a rainbow background

Makeup

Discover the Best (and Longest-Lasting) Perfumes to to Find Your Signature Scent

5 min read

Default Bottom Subscribe Module NEWDefault Bottom Subscribe Module NEW

Beauty Picked Just for You

Get 5 products worth up to $70

Exclusive access to epic deals up to 80% off

Starting at just $15/month. Cancel anytime.

Join IPSY