All Makeup Skin Hair Nails How-To Beauty Amplified Spoilers IPSY 101 Ingredient Index

Exclusive Spoilers: Inside Erin Foster & Sara Foster’s May IPSY Icon Box

By Maddie Aberman

Published on Apr 15, 2025 • 4 min read

When it comes to beauty, Erin Foster and Sara Foster have tried it all. They’ve borrowed (and never returned) each other’s favorites, tested every must-try trend, and know exactly what works—and what’s just hype. As beauty insiders, podcast hosts, and co-founders of FAVORITE DAUGHTER, they have an eye for the products that make getting ready easier, faster, and, most importantly, more fun.

Now, they’re letting you in on their beauty secrets with May’s IPSY Icon Box. Think effortless glow, low-maintenance glam, and skincare that actually delivers—because, as Erin puts it, “Looking put together is a full-time job, and frankly, we’re too busy for that."

Want to know what’s inside? We’ve got the first round of Icon Box product spoilers right here. And if you missed last month’s lineup, check out our spoilers page for past sneak peeks.

It's about glam time you treated yourself.

Join IPSY

Meet Your New Favorites: May’s Icon Box Product Lineup

Members who signed up for an Icon Box in May could receive the following.

1. MAKEUP BY MARIO SurrealSkin™ Awakening Concealer (MSRP $29)

Meet your new glow-up essential: this buildable concealer fakes a full night’s sleep with Lift & Lock™ tech that helps brighten, smooth, and visibly lift. Infused with caffeine to depuff and marine extracts for a tightening effect—it’s your secret to looking instantly refreshed.

2. THE ROOTIST BioBrew™ Fermented Leave-in Hair Serum for Damage Repair (MSRP $48)

This lightweight hair serum works double duty—helping to tame frizz and boost shine while helping to keep your scalp balanced and hydrated. Packed with Rootbiomic Ferment™ and Bio-Peptides, it’s the ultimate boost for your hair from root to tip.

3. OLEHENRIKSEN Glow2OH Dark Spot Toner (MSRP $35)

This powerhouse AHA toner works overtime to help smooth texture, even tone, and visibly fade dark spots. Packed with witch hazel, licorice root, and soothing botanicals, it’s your shortcut to brighter, more radiant-looking skin—no filter needed.

4. 111SKIN Anti Blemish Booster (MSRP $114)

This multitasking treatment helps target active blemishes, prevent future breakouts, and smooth skin while helping to reduce redness and post-blemish marks. With salicylic acid to clear pores, polylysine to calm irritation, and hyaluronic acid for hydration, it’s your secret weapon for clear, balanced, and glowing skin.

5. BOBBI BROWN COSMETICS Precise Brow Pencil (MSRP $25)

This brow pencil features an ultra-fine tip for effortless detailing and buildable color that lasts up to 24 hours. Whether you're going for soft and natural or bold and defined, this pencil’s got you covered without all the smudging or fuss.

6. NATASHA DENONA Bronze Eyeshadow Palette (MSRP $69)

Get your bronze on with this stunning eyeshadow palette featuring 15 warm, sun-kissed shades in rich coppers, bronzes, and dreamy neutrals. With velvety mattes, shimmering metallics, and dazzling foils, it’s your go-to for soft daytime looks or sultry nighttime glam.

7. MAKEUP BY MARIO Moisture Glow Lip Serum (MSRP $24)

Gloss? Balm? Lip oil? This viral lip serum does it all. Packed with nourishing vegan oils, it melts onto your lips for a dewy, plumped-up shine—zero stickiness, just hydration. Plus, the easy-to-use propel stick makes touch-ups a breeze.

8. ORIGINS Youthtopia Peptide Plumping Apple Cream (MSRP $54)

This antioxidant-rich peptide cream is powered by over 50,000 apple stem cells to deliver all-day hydration and help visibly plump and boost your skin’s bounce. With apple seed oil, squalane, and a splash of apple peel ferment, it’s like a juicy pick-me-up for a healthy-looking, glowing complexion.

9. JOOY Soothing Scalp Serum (MSRP $48)

Help detox and hydrate your scalp with this leave-in serum infused with fermented superfoods. Designed to purify, calm, and refresh, it promotes a balanced, nourished scalp—because healthy hair begins at the root.

10. PEAR NOVA Eye Duo Stick Shadow + Liner Set (MSRP $44.50)

Want to create a full eye look in less than 60 seconds? You need this eyeliner and eyeshadow duo. This set includes two eye duo sticks that are buildable, blendable, and velvety-smooth.

Liked this post? Share!

UP NEXT: We Need to Talk About Fall's IPSY Ultimate Box Lineup