All Makeup Skin Hair Nails How-To Beauty Amplified Spoilers IPSY 101 Ingredient Index

Spill the Beau-Tea: Erin Foster & Sara Foster’s Icon Box Is Here

Maddie Aberman DefaultMaddie Aberman Default
By
Published on Apr 8, 2025 • 4 min read
icon-box-erin-foster-sara-foster mobileicon-box-erin-foster-sara-foster desktop

When it comes to beauty, Erin Foster and Sara Foster have seen—and used—it all. They know what works, what doesn’t, and most importantly, what always gets you compliments. As the dynamic hosts of The World’s First Podcast and co-founders of FAVORITE DAUGHTER, Erin and Sara aren’t just beauty lovers—they’re beauty insiders, each with a signature style that’s as effortlessly cool as they are.

Now, they’re bringing that insider knowledge straight to you with May’s IPSY Icon Box. Inside, you’ll discover a mix of products designed to help you feel your best when you need it most. It’s like getting a backstage pass to some of the beauty essentials they swear by—whether they’re keeping it low-key or stepping into the spotlight.

"We look for products that not only work but do the work for you," says Erin. "Let’s be real—looking effortlessly put together is a full-time job, and frankly, we’re too busy for that. This Icon Box is all about making it easier, and a little more fun!"

Sara adds: “If there’s one thing we know, it’s how to make everything a sisterly competition, which means one of us is definitely going to take full credit for the whole thing. But that’s what sisters do, right? We’re competitive, but we also know how to share... sometimes."

It's about glam time you treated yourself.

Join IPSY
Default Middle Subscribe Module Image - MobileDefault Middle Subscribe Module Image - Desktop

The Ultimate Beauty Kit: Because Sisters Know Best

icon-box-erin-foster-sara-foster 01

This Icon Box is your one-stop-shop for an effortless beauty routine. Whether you’re looking for that “I woke up like this” vibe or the “I have my life together” glow, these are the products to help you get there. Want a sneak peek at a few of their faves? 

First up: KOSAS Blush Is Life ($29). "It’s a fresh, natural flush that makes you look alive—even if you’re not fully awake," says Erin. For a sun-kissed glow that’s practically effortless, reach for DRUNK ELEPHANT D-Bronzi Drops ($38). "I love this because it gives you a bronzy glow without looking like you tried too hard," says Sara.

Skincare is equally important to the sisters. FIRST AID BEAUTY Retinol Complex Serum ($95) is a cult favorite that smooths fine lines and helps even out skin tone. “Retinol is one of those things that really makes a difference. I never understood the hype until I used it," Erin shares.

For that post-facial glow, DERMALOGICA Daily Microfoliant ($68) is here to help. Sara’s take: “I swear by this stuff. It’s a game changer for smooth, glowing skin without the downtime." And because relaxation is part of the beauty process, ALO YOGA SKINCARE Magnesium Reset Spray ($48) ensures you unwind in style. "It’s the kind of spray that makes you feel like you’re at a spa," Sara says, “and who doesn’t want that?"

Sisterly Love (and a Little Stealthy Product Hoarding)

Sisterhood (whether it’s through family, friendship, or the connections we create over beauty) is at the core of this collection. "Let’s be real," says Erin. "One of us is going to take credit for this Icon Box. That’s just how it goes when you’re surrounded by people who get you. It’s competitive, but it’s also fun. Just be prepared to have your favorites ‘borrowed’—and never returned."

icon-box-erin-foster-sara-foster 02

That’s right, these beauty picks are perfect for sharing... or swiping for yourself. Whether you're team effortless glam or polished perfection, this box has everything you need to look like you’ve got it all together—even if you don’t.

"Beauty’s all about making life easier," Erin adds. "We’re all for products that are quick, effective, and make you feel confident, no matter where you are."

So, what’s the catch? Well, there isn’t one—except that once you and your sister (or BFF) see what’s inside this Icon Box, it’s likely that she will claim she discovered it first. But as Sara says: “Let her. Or don’t. We wouldn’t.”

Get your hands on Icon Box: Erin Foster and Sara Foster before it’s gone—and make sure to keep them in your own beauty stash (because trust us, you’re going to want to keep these to yourself).

Liked this post? Share!

UP NEXT: Icon Box FAQ: We’ve Got Answers to All of Your Icon Box Questions

Related Stories

Pink graphic featuring the words “Passport to Play” with subtle striped beach umbrellas in the background.Pink graphic featuring the words “Passport to Play” with subtle striped beach umbrellas in the background.

IPSY 101

Passport to Play: Summer Beauty Starts Here

3 min read

June 2026 IPSY theme graphic featuring the message “Blend the Rules” on a pink satin background with sparkling gem accents, capturing a bold, playful celebration of self-expression through beauty.June 2026 IPSY theme graphic featuring the message “Blend the Rules” on a pink satin background with sparkling gem accents, capturing a bold, playful celebration of self-expression through beauty.

IPSY 101

June Is for Taking Up Space

3 min read

A lineup of beauty products displayed on a reflective surface, featuring brands like Tarte, Anastasia Beverly Hills, First Aid Beauty, Color Wow, Rare Beauty, and Polite Society, along with two makeup brushes from TRESluce Beauty.A lineup of beauty products displayed on a reflective surface, featuring brands like Tarte, Anastasia Beverly Hills, First Aid Beauty, Color Wow, Rare Beauty, and Polite Society, along with two makeup brushes from TRESluce Beauty.

IPSY 101

How to Build Your IPSY Extra Bag Each Month

2 min read

Moody beauty still-life featuring the silhouettes of several skincare and makeup products.Moody beauty still-life featuring the silhouettes of several skincare and makeup products.

IPSY 101

We Need to Talk About Fall's IPSY Ultimate Box Lineup

3 min read

Model holding IPSY Ultimate beauty box, showcasing the black subscription box with a glowing, natural makeup look.Model holding IPSY Ultimate beauty box, showcasing the black subscription box with a glowing, natural makeup look.

IPSY 101

Get a First Look Inside the IPSY Ultimate: Summer Collection

3 min read

A flat lay of beauty products and a tan IPSY makeup bag with pink, red, and orange stripes on a pink background, featuring Clinique moisturizer, First Aid Beauty cream, Benefit primer, a brow pencil, and two pink-handled makeup brushes.A flat lay of beauty products and a tan IPSY makeup bag with pink, red, and orange stripes on a pink background, featuring Clinique moisturizer, First Aid Beauty cream, Benefit primer, a brow pencil, and two pink-handled makeup brushes.

IPSY 101

When Does My IPSY Ship? We Have Your Answer

4 min read

A lineup of luxury beauty products on a white background, featuring brands like BY MARIO, NARS, PATRICK TA, 111SKIN, ELEMIS, ODACITÉ, KEVYN AUCOIN, and Maison Louis Marie, arranged neatly to showcase skincare and makeup items.A lineup of luxury beauty products on a white background, featuring brands like BY MARIO, NARS, PATRICK TA, 111SKIN, ELEMIS, ODACITÉ, KEVYN AUCOIN, and Maison Louis Marie, arranged neatly to showcase skincare and makeup items.

IPSY 101

IPSY Ultimate FAQ: We’ve Got Answers to All of Your Ultimate Questions

3 min read

A hand with pink nails places a Supergoop! sunscreen tube into a colorful IPSY makeup bag with a wavy pink, red, and green pattern, blue zipper, and tassel, balanced on a pink board against an orange and pink background.A hand with pink nails places a Supergoop! sunscreen tube into a colorful IPSY makeup bag with a wavy pink, red, and green pattern, blue zipper, and tassel, balanced on a pink board against an orange and pink background.

IPSY 101

How IPSY Original Choice Works (and Why You’ll Love It)

2 min read

Default Bottom Subscribe Module NEWDefault Bottom Subscribe Module NEW

Beauty Picked Just for You

Get 5 products worth up to $70

Exclusive access to epic deals up to 80% off

Starting at just $15/month. Cancel anytime.

Join IPSY