The Secret to Longer, Fuller Lashes? Mascara Cocktailing

The Basics of Layering Mascara

There’s a little more to layering mascaras than applying different formulas. In fact, mascara cocktailing is more of a science, and there are several ways you can go about it. Layering formulas all comes down to knowing which types of mascara play nicely together.

For length and thickness, Corricelli recommends applying a lengthening mascara followed by a volumizing one. Meanwhile, a lifting formula paired with a lengthening formula offers long and wispy lashes. And if you’re down for a more playful look, you can also top off your favorite thickening mascara with a colorful formula.

There are some basics, however, that will help your look last all day (and night). Before applying your preferred mascaras, you’ll want to prep lashes by curling them to give them an additional lift. After that, it’s worth adding a mascara primer, too. “A mascara primer acts as your base layer, enhancing the pigment of your mascara and adding extra volume and length,” says Corricelli. “Make sure to apply your first mascara right after your primer for a smoother look—don’t let it dry down first.” Try this nourishing MAC lash primer to reduce flaking, or intensify the pigment of your lashes with this blue-tinted MORPHE lash primer.  

Your Guide to Mascara Cocktailing: Combining Different Formulas

With so many mascara combinations, you don’t have to settle for one look. But if you’re having trouble deciding on your next pairing, Corricelli recommends focusing on your lash concerns. Do you want long and wispy lashes, or plump and lifted lashes? A general rule of thumb (or in this case, lash) is to apply the most lightweight layer first, and save the thickest mascara for last. That typically means applying a lengthening mascara first to separate and define each lash. 

From there, you can add a voluminous mascara, a colorful mascara, or a waterproof mascara (or a combination of the three). That said, waterproof formulas make a great final addition to your mascara cocktail because they’ll grip other mascara layers and lock in your look for longer wear. Avoid using a waterproof mascara first since that will make removal harder at the end of the day. 

How to Prevent Clumping When Layering Mascara

Of course, more mascara increases the chances of clumpy lashes. To avoid excess product from gathering on your lashes, Corricelli likes to work fast. “While you might be tempted to let each coat of mascara dry, you want to apply your second mascara layer relatively quickly after your first,” she says. “Wait around 20 seconds between each coat to avoid smudging and clumping.” Don’t wait too long, since your lashes will set and become too brittle for additional layers. 

The only exception to this application method, Corricelli adds, is if you want to create a day-to-night look. “If you’re getting ready for a night out and don’t want to redo your makeup from earlier in the day, it’s okay to add another coat of mascara for an extra lift.” 

And while mascara cocktailing offers endless possibilities, you’ll want to avoid certain mascaras. “You don’t want to use fibre or tubing mascaras, since those don’t mix well with other formulas,” says Corricelli. Layering with these mascaras increases the risk of flaking, clumping, and fleeting wear time. 

Out of all the tips and tricks, however, clean application is key. Make sure to apply your mascara close to the root of your lashes, then wiggle the wand up as you sweep upward to work the product into your lashes. Corricelli also recommends placing the mascara wand at the base of your lash line, then blinking to help coat every single one of your lashes. For an extra-clean look, she uses a clean spoolie in between mascara layers to get rid of excess product. Following these techniques guarantees clean, fluttery lashes—no matter your preferred mascara cocktail. Cheers!